ADAM CHAPNICK
  • Adam Chapnick
    • Contact
    • Biography
    • Employment
    • Education
    • Academic Honours and research grants
    • Professional Administrative Experience
    • Advisory/Editorial Boards
    • Scholarly Assessments
    • Academic Associations
    • Additional Relevant Information
    • Testimonials
  • Teaching & Learning
    • Teaching Philosophy
    • Teaching Experience
    • Supervisions and Thesis Defence Committees >
      • Supervisions
      • Thesis Defence Committees
    • Refereed Conference Presentations (Teaching & Learning)
    • Publications (Teaching & Learning)
    • Teaching Blogs >
      • Virtually Learning
      • The First Sabbatical
      • The Scholarly Edition
    • Other Teaching & Learning Activities
  • Research
    • Articles
    • Book Chapters
    • Books and Edited Collections >
      • Situating Canada in a Changing World: Constructing a Modern and Prosperous Future
      • Canada on the United Nations Security Council
      • The Harper Era in Canadian Foreign Policy
      • Manuel de rédaction à l’usage des militaires
      • John W. Holmes: An Introduction, Special Issue of International Journal
      • Academic Writing for Military Personnel​
      • Canada’s Voice: The Public Life of John Wendell Holmes
      • Canadas of the Mind
      • The Middle Power Project
      • Through Our Eyes: An Alumni History of the University of Toronto Schools, 1960-2000
    • Conference Presentations
    • Newspaper and Newsletter Commentaries
    • Publications in Conference Proceedings
    • Reports
    • Reviews
    • Teaching & Learning Publications
  • Public Speaking
    • Guest Lectures & Invited Speeches
    • Invited Workshops & Presentations (Teaching & Learning)
    • Arrange a Lecture, Workshop, or Presentation
  • Adam Chapnick's Blog

Adam Chapnick's Blog

Please, please do politics differently, just don’t talk about it…

12/17/2019

0 Comments

 
​Almost every year, as part of my teaching duties at the Canadian Forces College, I accompany students to Question Period in Ottawa. The experience makes my skin crawl. For 45 minutes, grown women and men – many of whom have been extraordinarily successful in their previous careers and have reputations for carrying themselves with dignity – belittle one another like schoolyard bullies.
 
They heckle, demean, and interrupt their fellow elected colleagues – all, apparently, in support of the interests of Canadians like you and me.
 
Parliamentary behaviour – and the partisanship that drives it – is disgusting, and shameful. It seems to target women disproportionately, and it likely prevents some Canadians from even thinking about running for office.
 
It’s therefore hardly surprising that, every decade or so, some new political leader pledges to “do politics differently.”
 
Taking their cue from the Obama Democrats, who proposed in 2008 to “turn the page on the ugly partisanship in Washington,” in 2015, Justin Trudeau’s Liberals promised “real change.”
 
Touting reforms he had already begun to make in the Senate (kicking Liberal senators out of caucus; pledging to create a new, non-partisan and transparent appointment process to choose senators if elected), Trudeau claimed to embody a new way of doing politics.
 
To his credit, after the October 2015 election, there were noticeable changes.
 
During our 2016-18 visits to Question Period, a significant number of my students noted the difference between the behaviour of the Liberal members of Parliament (who did not applaud, and generally did not heckle), and the more obnoxious conduct of the opposition.
 
Some students wondered, as I have, how opposing members could possibly explain their behaviour in the house of Commons when they returned home to their kids. How would they respond to a school principal if their children were accused of, or the victims of, bullying?
 
It follows that many of my students emerged from Question Period with new respect for the Liberal government, regardless of what they thought of its policies.
 
Regrettably, much of that respect was likely lost by the 2019 election.
 
Question Period in 2019 was as bad as it’s ever been, if not worse. The election campaign that followed saw all of the major parties, Liberals included, resort to the same demeaning tactics that their advisors seem to think are necessary to “win” in Canada.
 
I couldn’t watch more than a few minutes of the leaders’ debates, and I get paid to talk about them. (I’ll always read the transcripts if I’m asked to comment publicly.)
 
So what gives?
 
I think that part of the problem was the 2015 promise itself. If the Liberals were genuinely committed to improving parliamentary behaviour, they should have paid closer attention to President Obama’s failed experiment.
 
By pledging to work with the Republicans, he gave his opponents an irresistible incentive to obstruct him. Cooperating in the Democrats in Congress would have enabled Obama to keep a promise and claim political victory.
 
The 2015 Trudeau Liberals asked Canadians to judge them based the state of decorum in the House of Commons.
 
In that context, it’s easy to understand why the opposition resisted calls to behave more civilly. They could not risk increasing the number of “promises achieved” on the TrudeauMeter.
 
Perhaps I’m naïve, but I don’t see the situation as hopeless. In Alberta, Jason Kenney has introduced a series of proposals to improve parliamentary decorum, some of which seem to be having at least a degree of effect. The key, I think, is that he isn’t bragging about what he’s done.
 
It seems to me that, to succeeed, long-term reform to political behaviour, especially in the House of Commons, needs to be a non-partisan initiative. The moment one party takes ownership, there’s reason to anticipate that things will only get worse.
 
***
 
To learn more about this issue, take a look at the Samara Centre for Democracy’s January 2016 Report, “Cheering or Jeering? Members of Parliament Open up about Civility in the House of Commons.” A PDF of the report is available here or here in French. It includes references to some of the published academic literature on the topic. Maclean’s has also published a number of pieces on heckling. I wrote about this issue myself a number of years ago while I was blogging for a Canadian newspaper.
 
To be notified of the next blog, follow me on Twitter @achapnick. 
I have a newsletter! You can subscribe at https://buttondown.email/achapnick.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Adam Chapnick is a professor of defence studies at the Royal Military College of Canada (RMC). The views expressed here are entirely his own.

    Archives

    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019

    Categories

    All
    Canadian Foreign Policy
    Diplomacy
    Iran
    Trudeau

    RSS Feed

Blog 

Click Here to Read the latest From Adam Chapnick

Newsletter

Subscribe to Adam Chapnick's Newsletter

Contact

  • Adam Chapnick
    • Contact
    • Biography
    • Employment
    • Education
    • Academic Honours and research grants
    • Professional Administrative Experience
    • Advisory/Editorial Boards
    • Scholarly Assessments
    • Academic Associations
    • Additional Relevant Information
    • Testimonials
  • Teaching & Learning
    • Teaching Philosophy
    • Teaching Experience
    • Supervisions and Thesis Defence Committees >
      • Supervisions
      • Thesis Defence Committees
    • Refereed Conference Presentations (Teaching & Learning)
    • Publications (Teaching & Learning)
    • Teaching Blogs >
      • Virtually Learning
      • The First Sabbatical
      • The Scholarly Edition
    • Other Teaching & Learning Activities
  • Research
    • Articles
    • Book Chapters
    • Books and Edited Collections >
      • Situating Canada in a Changing World: Constructing a Modern and Prosperous Future
      • Canada on the United Nations Security Council
      • The Harper Era in Canadian Foreign Policy
      • Manuel de rédaction à l’usage des militaires
      • John W. Holmes: An Introduction, Special Issue of International Journal
      • Academic Writing for Military Personnel​
      • Canada’s Voice: The Public Life of John Wendell Holmes
      • Canadas of the Mind
      • The Middle Power Project
      • Through Our Eyes: An Alumni History of the University of Toronto Schools, 1960-2000
    • Conference Presentations
    • Newspaper and Newsletter Commentaries
    • Publications in Conference Proceedings
    • Reports
    • Reviews
    • Teaching & Learning Publications
  • Public Speaking
    • Guest Lectures & Invited Speeches
    • Invited Workshops & Presentations (Teaching & Learning)
    • Arrange a Lecture, Workshop, or Presentation
  • Adam Chapnick's Blog